The Commanding Heights is an interesting artifact.
Will Manidis is, admittedly, one of those VC thinkfluencers — but, the least cursed example of his category. Frankly, I quite like his writing style; the lofty, Christian admonitions feel right at home with me. When I invited him to speak at Manifest, his refusal was the best I’ve heard — roughly “sorry, I think gambling is unethical”. (Honestly? Fair!)
So I was elated to receive an advance edition copy, and hope to make it worth their while by jotting down my thoughts on this artifact.
chapter by chapter
- Ravi: narrative, civil unrest in Bangalore downstream of AI. interesting hook, seems pretty impliclty “anti-AI”, surprisingly to me
- Overture:
- a paean to Leopold, obviously this is whole thing is kind of in homage
- the inventors of tech (gutenberg, railroads, EUV lithography) don’t always accrue the value.
- [ac] counterpoint: recent tech titans (Google, Amazon, SpaceX)? is this getting less true?
- soon will be a “turning point”? remaining sovereigns are… America and china and labs?
- confused: “what is sovereign” here?
- lot of emphasis on “dollars”, which I don’t get — maybe me being American, I already blindly assume USD is forever.
- what does dollar supremacy /neo-dollar imply…?
- 2008 GFC ⇒ wages stagnate, assets grow
- “K-shaped economy”
- seems to argue for the “one-man unicorn”. (why haven’t we seen this yet?)
- interesting. maybe think: is this true of Google? Amazon?
- “the frontier will remain on gpus in a black site in the desert”
- hmmm very Leopold-esque
- Ch1: Genesis
- reading about AI deployment makes me want to radically rehaul/reinvent Manifund
- points out the common nuclear analogy. interesting: postulates a unified global sovereign after atomics, which I hadn’t thought about
- will AI enable America to expand to encompass the world? (or the UN or sth?) might be an obvious result of dollarization. “united states of earth”
- 2: The Line
- okay, so: at current projections, hyperscaler capital is tapped and they have to start raising from “the common people”, retirement funds etc
- clear that Will & Joe have thought a bunch about financialization and private equity, of which i understand almost nothing
At the originary is the lab, which today owns very little, just the model. And the model is a curious thing to own. It costs billions to build and dollars and to run, but …
intelligence is the giveaway, loss leader for users & data, margins from being conduit
hyperscalers aren’t investing in one data center, they are buying call options on…
any living thing is like an animal. and machine intelligence is no different. it operates according to unwritten laws…
core points
- SF frontier labs are in the lead today, but not forever
- thesis is against the Anthropic Omnicompany
- economic upside ≠“commanding heights”, which are afforded to sovereigns, states
other thoughts
- Very little mention of xrisk/doomers, other than “rmn don’t kill us party”
- do cite epoch and metr tho
questions coming in:
- if not labs, then who? then what?