🎖️

Book Review: The Commanding Heights

The Commanding Heights is an interesting artifact.

Will Manidis is, admittedly, one of those VC thinkfluencers — but, the least cursed example of his category. Frankly, I quite like his writing style; the lofty, Christian admonitions feel right at home with me. When I invited him to speak at Manifest, his refusal was the best I’ve heard — roughly “sorry, I think gambling is unethical”. (Honestly? Fair!)

So I was elated to receive an advance edition copy, and hope to make it worth their while by jotting down my thoughts on this artifact.

chapter by chapter

  • Ravi: narrative, civil unrest in Bangalore downstream of AI. interesting hook, seems pretty impliclty “anti-AI”, surprisingly to me
  • Overture:
    • a paean to Leopold, obviously this is whole thing is kind of in homage
    • the inventors of tech (gutenberg, railroads, EUV lithography) don’t always accrue the value.
      • [ac] counterpoint: recent tech titans (Google, Amazon, SpaceX)? is this getting less true?
      At the originary is the lab, which today owns very little, just the model. And the model is a curious thing to own. It costs billions to build and dollars and to run, but …
    • soon will be a “turning point”? remaining sovereigns are… America and china and labs?
      • confused: “what is sovereign” here?
    • lot of emphasis on “dollars”, which I don’t get — maybe me being American, I already blindly assume USD is forever.
      • what does dollar supremacy /neo-dollar imply…?
    • 2008 GFC ⇒ wages stagnate, assets grow
      • “K-shaped economy”
      • seems to argue for the “one-man unicorn”. (why haven’t we seen this yet?)
      intelligence is the giveaway, loss leader for users & data, margins from being conduit
    • interesting. maybe think: is this true of Google? Amazon?
    • “the frontier will remain on gpus in a black site in the desert”
      • hmmm very Leopold-esque
  • Ch1: Genesis
    • reading about AI deployment makes me want to radically rehaul/reinvent Manifund
    • hyperscalers aren’t investing in one data center, they are buying call options on…
    • points out the common nuclear analogy. interesting: postulates a unified global sovereign after atomics, which I hadn’t thought about
      • will AI enable America to expand to encompass the world? (or the UN or sth?) might be an obvious result of dollarization. “united states of earth”
  • 2: The Line
    • okay, so: at current projections, hyperscaler capital is tapped and they have to start raising from “the common people”, retirement funds etc
    • clear that Will & Joe have thought a bunch about financialization and private equity, of which i understand almost nothing
    • any living thing is like an animal. and machine intelligence is no different. it operates according to unwritten laws…

core points

  • SF frontier labs are in the lead today, but not forever
    • thesis is against the Anthropic Omnicompany
  • economic upside ≠ “commanding heights”, which are afforded to sovereigns, states

other thoughts

  • Very little mention of xrisk/doomers, other than “rmn don’t kill us party”
    • do cite epoch and metr tho

questions coming in:

  • if not labs, then who? then what?