Have you ever been part of an admissions committee? Set up your own admissions pipeline? Have you before been the arbiter of character, the judge of talent, your finger poised above a “yes” or a “no”?
I have, and, it sucks. Reviewing applications is corrosive to the soul. I’m asked to strip away someone’s essential humanity, reducing them down to a question of whether they are useful or valuable, whether they are fit for inclusion. I don’t understand how one is supposed to engage in this process without emerging, fundamentally altered, more instrumental and less compassionate.
It sure would be nice to never have to judge anyone again.
Judge not, lest ye be judged
And: I have often been judged, and often found wanting. These days it’s more silent, when I ping an acquaintance to fund some project of mine, and never hear back. It’s almost a mercy — I can then pretend that they were simply too busy, maybe never even laid eyes on my proposal. (Though I’d ultimately prefer the grace of an explicit “no”).
It wasn’t always this way, though. I was rejected from my first EAG. From the Future Forum, from EA Bahamas. Every single time I’ve applied to YCombinator.
There’s this new website, aisafety.fail, which satirizes the silent rejections inherent in the space of AI safety. I don’t think AI safety does particularly badly — in fact, I expect its hiring norms to be exemplary compared to wider tech or nonprofits — but, I get it. One face of the AI safety shoggoth whispers, “apply, apply, we’re desperate for talent, you could save the world, just apply”. And you think, “wow, that could be me”, and you spend weeks of your life lurking and reading and build up the werewithal to apply, and then another shoggoth whacks you on the head, “didn’t you know? we wanted agency, we wanted talent. not, you.”